Alla Musica
DIY
- Reaction score
- 28
Hi Folks,
I'm looking for downlights that satisfy the following criteria: (1) white bezel; (2) fire-rated; (3) IP65 or above; (4) anti-glare; (5) GU10/MR16, not integrated LED. I've shortlisted the Integral Evofire Recessed (low-glare) and the JCC Fireguard Anti-Glare (IP65 variant).
To me, the Integral one is slightly better at aesthetics; however, it's made of steel and not aluminum, albeit powder-coated. As I'm fitting them at home outside the UK and by the ocean, the sea atmosphere might cause it to tarnish and rust quicker (start corroding sooner). This becomes a concern as I hope the fixture to be long-lasting. The JCC Fireguard, made of aluminum, may be theoretically better at this.
The Integral, though, is not without its merits and the JCC not without disadvantages: the Integral is double-insulated and has an open design; the JCC requires an earth connection. On the other hand, as earth connection is available, lack of double insulation isn't too problematic? The JCC comes as an aluminum can (rather than steel can), so should still conduct heat to a decent level?
Too much to compare, and I need help. I've attached a poll, or else you could please leave me a comment.
Link to both downlights:
www.downlightsdirect.co.uk
www.downlightsdirect.co.uk
Thanks all.
Best,
Chris
I'm looking for downlights that satisfy the following criteria: (1) white bezel; (2) fire-rated; (3) IP65 or above; (4) anti-glare; (5) GU10/MR16, not integrated LED. I've shortlisted the Integral Evofire Recessed (low-glare) and the JCC Fireguard Anti-Glare (IP65 variant).
To me, the Integral one is slightly better at aesthetics; however, it's made of steel and not aluminum, albeit powder-coated. As I'm fitting them at home outside the UK and by the ocean, the sea atmosphere might cause it to tarnish and rust quicker (start corroding sooner). This becomes a concern as I hope the fixture to be long-lasting. The JCC Fireguard, made of aluminum, may be theoretically better at this.
The Integral, though, is not without its merits and the JCC not without disadvantages: the Integral is double-insulated and has an open design; the JCC requires an earth connection. On the other hand, as earth connection is available, lack of double insulation isn't too problematic? The JCC comes as an aluminum can (rather than steel can), so should still conduct heat to a decent level?
Too much to compare, and I need help. I've attached a poll, or else you could please leave me a comment.
Link to both downlights:
Integral EvoFire Low Glare Fire Rated Downlight IP65
Integral EvoFire low glare downlight this fire rated and open rated. The low glare design positions the light source further back within the downlight to reduce eye discomfort from the LED. Low glare downlights have become increasingly popular in living rooms and bedrooms due to their design and...
www.downlightsdirect.co.uk
JCC Fireguard Anti-Glare GU10 Downlights
JCC FireGuard Anti-Glare GU10 downlights features significant advances for the GU10 downlight. JCC have redesigned the fire rated GU10 downlight and packed it with many technological features. Designed with the electrical contractor and end user in mind, the FireGuard series is easy to install...
www.downlightsdirect.co.uk
Thanks all.
Best,
Chris
- TL;DR
- Help me decide: Integral Evofire or JCC Fireguard IP65? (to be fitted in sea atmosphere)
